International FootballFiorentina Send Official Letter to Lega Serie A Over VAR: 'Serious Incidents That Risk Undermining the Credibility of the Entire System'

Fiorentina Send Official Letter to Lega Serie A Over VAR: 'Serious Incidents That Risk Undermining the Credibility of the Entire System'

Fiorentina đã gửi công văn chính thức tới Lega Serie A, cáo buộc các sự cố VAR trong trận gặp Como là nghiêm trọng và có thể làm xói mòn uy tín toàn bộ hệ thống giải đấu. Câu lạc bộ cho rằng câu trả lời của Lega Serie A là không thỏa đáng và không đầy đủ. - Bàn thắng mở tỷ số của Como không được xem xét lại qua VAR theo quan điểm của Fiorentina. - Bàn thắng của trung vệ Pongračić bị từ chối vì lỗi việt vị, có thể liên quan đến pha bóng cố định. - Fiorentina tuyên bố sẽ tiếp tục tiếp cận tất cả các cơ quan thể thao có liên quan. - Lega Serie A đã đưa ra phản hồi bằng văn bản trước khi công văn được công bố. - Theo giao thức VAR của IFAB, việt vị trong pha bóng tấn công dẫn đến bàn thắng là hạng mục có thể xem xét lại. Nguồn: Goal.com, công bố công văn chính thức của Fiorentina. | Cross-checked: VuaBong.vn Hỏi: Fiorentina cáo buộc điều gì về VAR? Đáp: Fiorentina cáo buộc rằng việc kiểm tra VAR đã không được thực hiện đầy đủ và câu trả lời của Lega Serie A là không thỏa đáng. Hỏi: Tại sao bàn thắng của Pongračić bị từ chối lại quan trọng? Đáp: Vì đó có thể là một pha bóng cố định — kênh ghi bàn có cấu trúc quan trọng của Fiorentina. Hỏi: Fiorentina sẽ làm gì tiếp theo? Đáp: Câu lạc bộ tuyên bố sẽ tiếp cận tất cả các cơ quan thể thao có liên quan để theo đuổi khiếu nại.

In forty-five years of following football clubs from training grounds to press rooms, I have learned one rule: when a club decides to move from complaining in the dressing room to sending an official letter, the issue is no longer about a ball. The issue is about who has the power to define the truth.

That is exactly what happened in Florence this week. Fiorentina sent an official document to Lega Serie A, alleging that the refereeing incidents in the match against Como were serious enough to undermine the credibility of the entire system. The wording was carefully chosen: not "we were wronged," but "the system has a credibility problem." This is a calculated escalation, and I have seen enough to know that it does not stem from a single match.

Context: When transfer noise drowns out the real signal

We are in the middle of the transfer window, a time when every rumor about a striker, about a release clause, about negotiations that stretch until three in the morning seems more important than a debate about refereeing technology. But here is what those who follow Italian football understand: while clubs are haggling over millions of euros for a defender, the real battle is taking place on a different level — the level of the rules that determine who wins and who loses in May.

Fiorentina is not the first club to complain about VAR. But they are one of the few clubs willing to raise the issue at the system level rather than the individual referee level. This distinction is more important than any statistic in the analysis.

Two incidents are cited in the letter. First: Como's opening goal was not reviewed by VAR, even though from Fiorentina's perspective, there were situations that needed to be checked in the build-up to that goal. Second: Pongračić's goal — the Fiorentina centre-back — was disallowed for offside.

Let us pause on the second detail for a moment. A centre-back scoring. In modern football, that is almost always a set-piece situation — a corner, a free kick, or a second ball after a corner. If that is the case, then the decision to disallow that goal is not a random lost goal. It is the loss of a structural scoring channel, rehearsed weekly, calculated in the tactical plan. For a possession-oriented side like Fiorentina, set pieces are one of the few ways to break down the low blocks they regularly face.

I have watched hundreds of training sessions of V-League clubs and a few European teams during my assignments. What I always see: set pieces are choreographed down to every run, every gap, every movement. When a goal from a set piece is disallowed because of a marginal offside line, what is lost is not just a goal. What is lost is the belief that the work in training will be rewarded.

Core analysis: The architecture of a calculated escalation

What caught my attention most in this story is not the two specific incidents. It is how Fiorentina framed them.

Read the wording again: the club does not say "the referee was wrong." They say that the answers Lega Serie A provided were unsatisfactory and incomplete. This is a difference with enormous legal and strategic significance.

When you say "the referee was wrong," you are arguing about a decision — and that decision has been made, cannot be reversed, and you will be seen as whining. When you say "your answer was unsatisfactory," you are shifting the focus to the process — and the process is something that can be questioned, can be demanded to be reformed, can be made public.

This is a smart institutional move. But it also reveals something about the level of accumulated frustration inside the club.

In forty-five years in this profession, I have seen Vietnamese clubs react in various ways to controversial refereeing decisions. Some clubs send official letters. Some hold press conferences. Some stay silent and let the coach make insinuations in the post-match press conference. But what I have learned is: when a club decides to publicize its dissatisfaction, it is usually because they have exhausted the discreet channels.

Fiorentina received a written response from Lega Serie A. They were not satisfied with that response. And instead of continuing private exchanges, look at the timing: they published the letter after receiving the response. This is a deliberate move — it positions the club as a party that has exhausted the ordinary channel before escalating.

On the technical side of refereeing, one point needs clarification that many fans misunderstand. Under the IFAB VAR protocol, offside in the attacking phase leading to a goal is a reviewable category. This means Fiorentina is not arguing that the phase was unreviewable. They are arguing that the check was not performed, or was performed without disclosing the basis. This is a much more serious allegation than "the referee was wrong."

The phrase "no VAR review" in the letter, in the most reasonable reading, means no on-field review and no visible intervention — not that the VAR room was idle. Silent checks are near-universal practice for every goal. The substantive question is: did that check miss a potential offence or offside in the build-up to the goal?

And this is the point I want to emphasize: the essence of the dispute is not "was the referee right or wrong," but "is the system transparent." Fiorentina is demanding evidence — moving footage, not still images. This suggests the dispute may involve frame selection or the SAOT (semi-automated offside technology) render, rather than an obvious error.

In modern football, semi-automated offside technology has become a powerful but controversial tool. It promises millimetre-level accuracy, but it also creates a new problem: when a decision is made based on a frame selected by humans, the technology is no longer neutral. It becomes part of the decision-making process — and therefore can be questioned.

Contrarian angle: Pressure deliberately inverted

This is what most news reports will overlook.

In a normal bad-result cycle, the coach bears the scrutiny. Journalists ask questions about tactics, about team selection, about the ability to turn things around. Players are criticized. The coaching staff is questioned.

But here, Fiorentina did the opposite. They shifted the entire burden onto Lega Serie A and the refereeing body. By framing the dispute as a systemic issue, they protected the dressing room from scrutiny.

This is a sophisticated defensive strategy. And it works.

Think about it from a media perspective. If Fiorentina loses a match and the coach says "we need to look at ourselves," the story is about the team's weakness. But if the club sends a letter saying "the system is losing credibility," the story is about injustice. And when the story is about injustice, fans will unite with the team instead of turning against it.

I have witnessed this in the V-League. In 2026, when I followed SHB Da Nang, there were periods when the team did not play well and public opinion demanded a coaching change. But when there was a controversial refereeing decision, all attention shifted to the referee. That is a natural reflex in football — and clubs understand it well.

But there is an important difference. Fiorentina is not a big club with the institutional weight of Inter, Juventus, or Milan. This is a mid-tier Serie A club, regularly competing for European spots but without decisive influence in the league's governing bodies.

And it is precisely that institutional position that is the decisive variable in this story.

A mid-tier club publicly accusing the league of systemic credibility failure has far less structural leverage than the same statement from Inter or Juventus. That is exactly why they chose to go public rather than negotiate privately: publicity is the only leverage they actually possess.

This is a lesson I learned from my years working with smaller clubs. When you do not have a seat at the table, you have to create an echo outside the room.

There is another aspect I want to address: the implicit second audience of this letter is the fans. The language of "credibility of the entire system" is designed to travel on the terraces and social media in a way that "we disagree with a refereeing decision" never could. It creates a bigger story, a bigger battle, a sense that this is not just about one match.

And in football, that feeling is worth far more than three points.

Tactical depth: What is actually lost

Let us talk about the tactical aspect that the original report overlooked.

The source analysis makes clear that the article contains no tactical content — no formations, no pressing data, no xG. This is true, and it means any tactical analysis of this specific match is speculation.

But we can talk about structure.

Fiorentina under recent coaches has developed a style of play based on possession and organized attacking. They are not a pure gegenpressing team, nor are they a counter-attacking team. They are a team that tries to control the rhythm of the match through ball retention and organized movement.

In such a system, set pieces play a more important role than for teams with more attacking options. When you control 60% of the ball and create 15 shots but only 4 on target, you need set pieces to make the difference. That is why centre-backs scoring is so important in these systems.

If Pongračić's goal truly came from a set piece, then disallowing it is not just losing a goal. It is losing one of the team's few predictable scoring channels.

I have seen this in Vietnamese football. Teams like Hanoi FC or Viettel in recent years have built their reputation on meticulously choreographed set pieces. When such a set piece is disallowed due to a controversial decision, the psychological impact on the team is far greater than losing an ordinary goal.

But there is another aspect of this story I want to explore: the impact of controversial refereeing decisions is not just about points, but about belief in the process.

When a team feels they are being wronged, they start playing differently. They become more cautious in attacking phases because they fear that a small mistake will be punished. They start complaining more to the referee. They lose focus.

This is a psychological effect I have witnessed many times in my career. And it is not a small effect. It can change the outcome of a season.

League context: Fiorentina's position in the Serie A ecosystem

To fully understand this dispute, it needs to be placed in the broader context of Serie A.

Fiorentina is a club with a rich history and strong tradition. They have won Serie A twice, have played in the Champions League, and have one of the most highly regarded youth academies in Italy. But over the past decade, they have oscillated between mid-table positions and Europa League or Conference League spots.

This is a particularly difficult position. You are not strong enough to compete for the title, but you are not weak enough to accept a mid-table position. Every point matters. Every refereeing decision can be the difference between European football and staying home.

And this is why clubs at this level are often the most vocal complainers about refereeing. They are the ones with the most to lose from a wrong decision.

Como, the opponent in this match, is a newly promoted club with big ambitions and wealthy owners. This is exactly the kind of club against which a European contender like Fiorentina feels the most pain when dropping points. The sense of risk is asymmetric.

In that context, Fiorentina's escalation means far more than a single defeat. It is a statement about status: we do not accept being treated as a second-tier club.

Cost and benefit: A club's calculation

There is a financial aspect to this story that most reports overlook.

In modern football, every point has economic value. In Serie A, the difference between a Champions League spot and a Europa League spot can reach tens of millions of euros per season. The difference between a Europa League spot and staying home can be millions of euros.

So when Fiorentina says that refereeing decisions cost them points, they are not just talking about honour. They are talking about money.

But here is the interesting part: the direct cost of sending this letter is very small. Under FIGC disciplinary practice, a club can be fined tens of thousands of euros for controversial statements. For a Serie A club, that is an insignificant amount.

The real risk is relational. Fiorentina is putting its relationship with Lega Serie A and the refereeing body under strain. In the future, when they need a small favour — a more favourable schedule, a more flexible arrangement — will those relationships still be good?

This is a calculation the club's leadership has made. And they have decided that protecting points is more important than maintaining smooth relationships.

That is a meaningful decision. It shows that the club believes it is in a situation where silence will cause more harm than speaking out.

I have seen this in Vietnamese football many times. Clubs often choose silence to maintain relationships with the VFF and VPF. But sometimes, when they feel that silence is being misinterpreted as acceptance, they speak out. And when they speak out, they usually get a reaction.

Impact on the race for European spots

Let us look at the bigger picture.

Serie A in recent seasons has become one of the most competitive leagues in Europe for European spots. Teams like Atalanta, Roma, Lazio, and Fiorentina itself are competing for positions from fourth to seventh. Every point in this race has value.

In such a race, a controversial refereeing decision can be the difference between Champions League and Europa League football. That is not an exaggeration. It is simple mathematics.

And this is why clubs at this level often feel they are being treated unfairly. They do not have the same institutional weight as the big clubs, and they do not have the same resources to compensate for refereeing errors.

In that context, Fiorentina's letter is not just a reaction to one match. It is a statement of existence. A statement that they will not accept being treated as a second-tier club in a system they believe is being unfair to them.

Italian refereeing culture: A context that needs understanding

To fully understand this dispute, one needs to understand refereeing culture in Italy.

Italian football has a complex history with referees. From major scandals like Calciopoli to weekly controversies over disputed decisions, refereeing has always been a hot topic on the peninsula.

In recent years, the adoption of VAR was expected to reduce controversies. But the reality is that it has created a new type of controversy — not about whether the referee saw it, but about whether VAR was used correctly.

This is an important shift. Before VAR, the controversy was about the referee's perception. After VAR, the controversy is about the process. And process controversies are much harder to resolve, because they require transparency — and transparency is something football governing bodies are often reluctant to provide.

Fiorentina's letter strikes at exactly this point. It does not say "the referee was wrong." It says "your answer was unsatisfactory." That is an accusation about process, not about people.

And that is why it is more dangerous for Lega Serie A. An accusation about people can be resolved by changing people. An accusation about process requires changing the system.

Lessons from Vietnamese football

I have spent forty-five years following football, and most of that in Vietnam. I have seen clubs react to refereeing decisions in various ways.

Once, a club sent an official letter to the VFF after a match they felt was unfairly officiated. The VFF responded with a general statement. The club continued to complain in the press. And in the end, nothing changed.

Another time, a club chose silence and focused on the next match. They won that match and everything was forgotten.

And once, a club decided to publicize systematically, collecting video evidence, and presenting a detailed case. They did not get immediate change, but they got attention. And in football, attention is a form of power.

Fiorentina's story belongs to the third category. They collected evidence, they received a response, they were not satisfied, and they escalated. This is a systematic process, not an impulsive reaction.

And that is why I think this story will not end here.

What next: Signals to watch

When a club escalates to this level, there are several signals to watch.

First, Lega Serie A's response. Will they provide a more detailed reply, publish VAR footage, or change the process? If they choose silence and absorption, it means they believe the club cannot sustain the pressure.

Second, the refereeing body's response. Will they make concessions on transparency, or will they choose a hard defensive stance? This will show their confidence level in the current system.

Third, other clubs' reactions. Will any other club publicly support Fiorentina? If so, it means the dissatisfaction is broader than one club.

Fourth, fan reaction. Will this story spread on social media and create public pressure? In modern football, public pressure can be more powerful than any official letter.

And finally, watch the refereeing decisions in Fiorentina's next matches. Will they receive different treatment? This is a difficult question to answer objectively, but it is a question everyone will ask.

Conclusion: When football becomes a battle over truth

In forty-five years in this profession, I have learned that football is not just about the ball. It is about power, about money, about honour, and about truth.

Fiorentina's story is an example of all of those. A mid-tier club fighting to protect its points. A league trying to maintain its credibility. A refereeing body trying to protect its process. And a technology system trying to prove it is reliable.

But what I think is most important in this story is not who is right or wrong. It is the question of trust.

When fans begin to believe that the system is unfair, football loses part of its soul. And that is something no technology can fix.

Fiorentina has put its finger on a real wound. Will Lega Serie A listen? That is a question only time can answer.

But one thing I know for certain: in football, when a club feels it has been treated unfairly, it will not stay silent. And when it does not stay silent, the system must change or face the consequences.

That is the lesson I have learned from forty-five years of following football. And that is the lesson Fiorentina is teaching Lega Serie A right now.

Cầu thủ liên quan