Domestic FootballLucao Scores Hat-trick Against Haiphong: When Loyalty Is Compared to a 'Dog'

Lucao Scores Hat-trick Against Haiphong: When Loyalty Is Compared to a 'Dog'

core_answer: Lucas Vinicius (Lucao) scored a hat-trick as Ninh Binh FC defeated Haiphong FC 4-1 at Lach Tray Stadium on September 5, 2026 in Round 1 of V-League 2026-2027. The official HPFC Capital fanpage posted a controversial comparison calling Lucao a 'dog' for not showing loyalty. The post went viral, sparking nationwide debate about professional conduct in Vietnamese football. Most fans condemned the post as uncivilized, arguing that foreign players have the right to transfer freely. Lucao previously played for Haiphong from 2023-2025 (39 goals total) before moving to Cong Thanh - Viettel and then Ninh Binh. The fanpage has not deleted the post as of publication.
key_facts: Ninh Binh FC beat Haiphong FC 4-1 at Lach Tray Stadium on September 5, 2026 — Round 1 V-League 2026-2027; Lucas Vinicius scored a hat-trick (minutes 34, 67, 82) against his former club Haiphong; HPFC Capital fanpage posted 'Nuôi chó để thấy chó trung thành' (You feed a dog to see its loyalty) — post not deleted as of press time; Lucao played for Haiphong 2023-2025: 39 total goals (18 in 2023-2024, 21 in 2024-2025); Last season, Lucao scored a brace for Cong Thanh - Viettel in a 2-1 win at Lach Tray against Haiphong; The post received major backlash even from Haiphong fans themselves on the page; HPFC Capital fanpage has approximately 7,800 followers
source: Match report + social media analysis | September 5-6, 2026 | Lach Tray Stadium, Haiphong | V-League 2026-2027 Round 1
related_qa: Why did the HPFC Capital fanpage post draw criticism from Haiphong fans themselves? Because the post used dehumanizing language comparing a former player to an animal, violating basic standards of professional club communication and sparking nationwide backlash; What does this incident reveal about Vietnamese football fan culture? It exposes the gap between professional football ambitions and outdated fan expectations — some fans still view player transfers as 'betrayal' rather than a normal economic transaction protected by contract law; How should V-League clubs handle social media conduct? Experts recommend clubs adopt formal social media codes of conduct and the league organizer should implement penalty mechanisms for discriminatory or abusive online behavior

On the evening of September 5, 2026, Lach Tray Stadium witnessed a match that football fans in Vietnam will remember for a long time. Ninh Binh FC traveled to face Haiphong and pulled off a stunning 4-1 comeback victory. The performance was orchestrated by a familiar name to Haiphong supporters — Lucas Vinicius, known as Lucao, a former Haiphong striker from 2026-2026, now wearing Ninh Binh colors after scoring a historic hat-trick at his old home ground.

Three goals in one match. Three runs to the corner flag to celebrate. Three times the Lach Tray stands fell silent then erupted in boos. And three times an official club fanpage — HPFC Capital — posted what the Vietnamese online community called the "most uncivilized comparison of the 2026-2027 V-League season": "You feed a dog to see its loyalty."

The story extends far beyond a 4-1 victory. It sparked a broader debate about how professional football should be understood and whether loyalty is something foreign players owe their former clubs.

Memories that linger at Lach Tray

Lucas Vinicius was no stranger to Haiphong football. He joined the club in 2026 and quickly became their primary striker. Across two seasons, Lucao scored 18 and 21 goals respectively — numbers impressive enough for any V-League club. He was the third-highest scorer in the 2026-2026 season.

But professional football doesn't run on emotions. In the 2026-2026 season, Lucao moved to Cong Thanh - Viettel and scored a brace against his former club Haiphong at Lach Tray in a 2-1 victory. At that time, he celebrated enthusiastically but received no major backlash — perhaps because two goals weren't enough to wound.

This time was different. A hat-trick, at Lach Tray, in Ninh Binh colors — a team many considered less competitive than Cong Thanh - Viettel or even Haiphong. Lucao's three goals came at crucial moments: an equalizer in the 34th minute from a quick counter-attack, a penalty in the 67th minute, and a long-range strike in the 82nd minute to make it 4-1. All were scored in central areas — where a technically skilled Brazilian striker would maximize his advantage.

HPFC Capital and the controversial post

The official Haiphong FC fanpage posted immediately after the final whistle. The content compared Lucas Vinicius to a dog, implying the player was disloyal to the club that once paid his salary.

The post had just 7,800 followers — small compared to major club pages in Hanoi or Ho Chi Minh City. But it was screenshotted, reshared across dozens of football forums nationwide, and exploded into the biggest controversy of the opening week of V-League 2026-2027.

Even on HPFC Capital's own page, the post drew significant negative reactions. Haiphong fans who consider themselves advocates of civilized football spoke out against the admin's behavior.

"I'm embarrassed for Haiphong people because of an admin like this," one commenter wrote.

"This page admin doesn't represent Haiphong fans," another responded.

Those reactions revealed that Vietnamese football fans are not uniform in their views. A small minority agreed with the fanpage's stance: "Right, the dog came back and bit three times and still celebrated happily."

But the majority spoke up. And those voices deserve deeper analysis.

Professional football doesn't run on loyalty

To understand why most of the Vietnamese football community opposed HPFC Capital's post, the story must be placed in the broader context of global professional football.

Lucas Vinicius came to Vietnam in 2026 as a foreign player recruited by Haiphong's management. He signed a labor contract, received a salary, performed his duties, and fulfilled his contractual obligations. When his contract expired and he received a better offer from another club, he had every right to transfer — a fundamental right of any professional player worldwide. No clause forced a foreign player to stay at a club once his contract expired.

This is a foundational principle of modern football. From Lionel Messi leaving Barcelona to Kylian Mbappe parting ways with Paris Saint-Germain — all operate under the same rule: contracts are economic transactions, not emotional bonds.

One fan articulated it bluntly online: "Playing football is working for a salary. Just like going to work and getting paid. The boss doesn't feed you. I'm the same as him (Lucao) — whoever pays more, I go there. Simple as that."

Another wrote: "Watch civilized football, gentlemen. It's also just a job to earn money. You work for whoever pays you."

These comments reflect a growing trend among young Vietnamese football fans: viewing football as an entertainment industry, not a stage for patriotism or local sentiment.

History repeats with other foreign players

Lucao's case is not the first in V-League where a foreign player scored against his former club and faced negative fan reactions.

Previously, another foreign striker scored against his old club at his old home ground and celebrated. At that time, the fans cheered instead of booed — because they understood the player had given his all during his tenure and the transfer was the club's decision, not the player's fault.

Another case: a foreign midfielder from Africa moved from Hanoi FC to HCMC FC, then faced his old team at Hang Day. He played hard but didn't celebrate his goal against Hanoi. Pitch-side journalists noted the gesture was "wise but somewhat forced." Fans on both sides respected that decision.

But Lucao didn't do that. He celebrated three times — fully, passionately, emotionally. And for a segment of Haiphong fans, that was unacceptable.

Tactical analysis: Why did Ninh Binh win so decisively?

Ninh Binh's 4-1 victory at Lach Tray was no coincidence. Entering Round 1 of V-League 2026-2027, Ninh Binh was rated in the mid-table. Haiphong, despite losing Lucao, retained their core squad and signed two new foreign players. Yet the gap on the pitch was substantial.

Tactically, Ninh Binh employed a quick counter-attacking style with Lucas Vinicius as the focal point in the central channel. He constantly moved between both penalty boxes, drawing at least two opposing defenders each time he received the ball. His three goals came in three different situations: speed counter-attack, penalty, and long-range shot — demonstrating finishing versatility that Haiphong's defense had no answer for.

Haiphong lacked a high-pressing forward in that match. Their midfield was pulled out of position multiple times by Ninh Binh's long balls over the top. Haiphong's young goalkeeper — a prospect with high expectations — committed an error on the second goal with a slow reaction to the penalty kick.

In short, Ninh Binh deserved their win. And Lucao deserved to celebrate.

Vietnamese football at a fan culture crossroads

The HPFC Capital incident raises a bigger question for Vietnamese football: Are Vietnamese fans truly ready for professional football?

Professional football requires three core elements: professional players, professional clubs, and professional fans. While players and clubs have made significant progress over the past decade — clearer contracts, better youth development investment, more organized leagues — fan culture is still in a transitional phase.

A significant portion of Vietnamese fans still tie football to intense local emotions: the team is "family," players are "children," and transfers are "betrayal." This mindset is emotionally understandable but directly contradicts the logic of modern football operations.

When a Premier League or La Liga club releases a player, no one calls it "betrayal." When a player's contract expires and he moves to a rival, it is a legal right protected by labor and sports law. For an official Haiphong FC fanpage — representing a professional sports organization — to post content comparing a player to a "dog" reveals the gap between professionalization ambitions and the actual fan culture reality in Vietnam.

What the experts say

A Vietnamese football expert with over 15 years of experience working in Southeast Asian football environments commented on a sports channel that the incident reflects "immaturity in club brand management" in Vietnam. "Social media is a brand-building tool, not a trash bin for emotions. A post like this from an official fanpage will affect future foreign player recruitment. Who wants to join a club whose fanpage openly insults former players?"

A veteran sports journalist in Hanoi suggested this is "an opportunity for the V-League to self-review fan and club conduct standards." He proposed that clubs should have social media codes of conduct, and the league organizer should have penalty mechanisms for discriminatory or personally abusive behavior online.

Closing: Where should loyalty come from?

Lucas Vinicius owes Haiphong nothing beyond the respect he showed during his time there — and he gave that fully, scoring 39 goals for the club over two seasons. When he left, he followed proper transfer procedures. When he returned and scored, he followed the rules of the game.

Loyalty in professional football should flow in two directions: clubs loyal to players by paying on time, providing good training environments, and treating them fairly; players loyal by giving their all while wearing the club's colors. That is an equal transaction, not an open-ended contract.

As for HPFC Capital? The page has not deleted the post as of this article's completion. They have that right. But the Vietnamese football community also has the right to acknowledge: a professional club fanpage should not post content that makes everyone involved — both players and fans — uncomfortable.

Vietnamese football is developing. V-League 2026-2027 has already showcased Ninh Binh's impressive performance and Lucas Vinicius's brilliance. Hopefully, the memorable stories of this season will revolve around goals, tactics, and sportsmanship — not uncivilized social media posts.

Cầu thủ liên quan