International FootballIslamabad High Court Orders PESCO to Cover Treatment for Nine-Year-Old Girl Who Lost Both Hands in Electric Shock

Islamabad High Court Orders PESCO to Cover Treatment for Nine-Year-Old Girl Who Lost Both Hands in Electric Shock

**Câu trả lời cốt lõi** (≤60 từ): Tòa Thượng thẩm Islamabad đã bác đơn của Công ty Cung cấp Điện lực Peshawar (PESCO), buộc đơn vị này chi trả chi phí điều trị và phục hồi cho Lubaba, bé gái chín tuổi mất cả hai bàn tay trong tai nạn điện tháng 7 năm 2021 tại làng Pir Qila, huyện Charsadda, tỉnh Khyber Pakhtunkhwa. **Sự kiện chính**: - Tai nạn xảy ra tháng 7 năm 2021 tại làng Pir Qila, huyện Charsadda, tỉnh Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, Pakistan. - Thanh tra Liên bang ra quyết định bồi thường cho Lubaba vào ngày 24 tháng 10 năm 2024. - Phủ Tổng thống chỉ thị PESCO chịu chi phí y tế vào ngày 30 tháng 10 năm 2025. - Tòa Thượng thẩm Islamabad bác đơn kháng cáo của PESCO đối với chỉ thị này. - Thẩm phán Azam Khan chỉ định Viện Y học Phục hồi Chức năng Lực lượng Vũ trang (AFIRM) tại Rawalpindi đánh giá thương tật. **Nguồn**: The Express Tribune (báo tiếng Anh của Pakistan), bản tin về phán quyết của Tòa Thượng thẩm Islamabad. **Hỏi đáp liên quan**: - Hỏi: Ai chịu trách nhiệm chi trả điều trị cho Lubaba? Đáp: Công ty Cung cấp Điện lực Peshawar (PESCO), theo quyết định của Thanh tra Liên bang và chỉ thị của Phủ Tổng thống, được Tòa Thượng thẩm Islamabad duy trì. - Hỏi: PESCO có phải là tổ chức bóng đá không? Đáp: Không; PESCO là Công ty Cung cấp Điện lực Peshawar, một đơn vị phân phối điện nhà nước Pakistan. - Hỏi: AFIRM có vai trò gì trong vụ việc? Đáp: AFIRM là cơ sở được tòa chỉ định để đánh giá tình trạng thương tật và nhu cầu phục hồi chức năng của Lubaba.

In July 2026, in the village of Pir Qila in Charsadda district, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa province, a power line snapped and fell into a residential area. The current passed through the body of a young girl named Lubaba, and she lost both hands. More than four years later, her story is no longer a simple infrastructure incident; it has become the center of a chain of administrative and judicial decisions stretching from a federal ombudsman, through the President's Office, to the Islamabad High Court. The central party in the latest ruling is the Peshawar Electric Supply Company (PESCO), a state-owned Pakistani power distribution utility responsible for operating the grid in the area where the accident occurred. The case came to light after the Federal Ombudsman, a statutory grievance-redressal institution in Pakistan, issued a decision on October 24, 2026 ordering PESCO to pay compensation and cover Lubaba's treatment costs. That decision marked the first time a federal administrative oversight body affirmed the financial responsibility of an electric utility for the lasting injury of an individual. On October 30, 2026, the President's Office issued a directive requiring PESCO to bear the full cost of the girl's medical care, including the possibility of treatment abroad if domestic rehabilitation facilities proved inadequate. The directive raised the commitment from compensation to comprehensive medical coverage, placing the burden on the infrastructure operator. PESCO then filed a petition with the Islamabad High Court challenging the directive, but the court dismissed it. Justice Azam Khan, who presided over the hearing, ordered that Lubaba be brought to the Armed Forces Institute of Rehabilitation Medicine (AFIRM) in Rawalpindi for an assessment of her disability. The court's decision covered matters relating to prosthetic limbs, rehabilitation, and a long-term care plan for her. AFIRM, a military medical facility specializing in rehabilitation, became the designated venue for determining the extent of her injury and her medical support needs in the years ahead. The most notable point in the ruling is how the court interpreted the responsibility of a power distribution company. The court made clear that electric utilities are responsible not only for supplying power but also for protecting human lives and meeting safety requirements. This is a principle of legal liability, established in the context of an infrastructure failure that left a child with permanent consequences. This reasoning broadens the scope of a state enterprise's obligations, from service provision to safeguarding community safety in its service territory. During the proceedings, PESCO put forward a defense based on allegations of negligence and admitted that the affected area had numerous illegal connections. That argument points to a systemic problem in the enforcement of electrical safety in the locality, and it also raises the question of the grid operator's responsibility for risks existing in the area it runs. The admission of illegal connections also implies that gaps in safety control may have existed for a long time before the incident. The case did not proceed smoothly. The family's initial complaint was upheld, but the findings were later withdrawn during a review, before the President's Office directive restored the compensation obligation. This sequence shows that the question of liability went through a contested procedural history, with several reversals. The fact that a single case had to pass through three levels — the federal ombudsman, the President's Office, and the court — reflects the complexity of the grievance-redressal mechanism involving state-owned enterprises. For years, Pakistan has faced power outages and pressure on its distribution system. Companies such as PESCO operate extensive grids in which illegal connections and electricity theft are persistent problems. This context makes incidents involving fallen lines, short circuits, and tragic accidents a constant concern for residents in many areas, especially where infrastructure is degraded and inspection and maintenance are weak. The Islamabad High Court ruling comes at a time when public opinion in Pakistan is increasingly focused on infrastructure safety and the responsibility of state-owned enterprises. For a nine-year-old girl, the consequences of the accident do not end at the moment of the incident; they extend across the rest of her life. Her need for prosthetic limbs, rehabilitation, and medical care will follow her for years, imposing a long-term financial obligation on the party held responsible. This is not a one-time expense but an extended commitment tied to her recovery. From a legal standpoint, this is a precedent emphasizing that a power distributor's safety obligation cannot be separated from its supply obligation. An electric utility operating a grid in an area with illegal connections must face liability when those risks harm residents. The ruling also shows that the court is willing to uphold an executive-branch directive when that directive aims to protect the interests of the vulnerable. The case also reflects the gap between regulation and enforcement in the electricity infrastructure system of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa province. The admission of numerous illegal connections shows that gaps in safety control can create prolonged risks, not only for one household but for the entire community. Areas with many illegal connections are often places where safety standards are neglected, and the consequences tend to fall on residents least able to protect themselves. For PESCO, the ruling means the utility must balance financial obligations against operational responsibility. Ensuring Lubaba's treatment, including the possibility of treatment abroad, requires considerable resources. At the same time, the case imposes a requirement to improve inspection and maintenance of the grid and to address illegal connections in order to prevent similar incidents in the future. Oversight bodies in Pakistan are likely to monitor PESCO's compliance closely. If the utility delays or fails to comply, the case could return to court with enforcement demands. In a case involving a child and permanent injury, pressure from public opinion and public authorities tends to be greater than in ordinary infrastructure disputes. The open question is whether PESCO will fully comply with the ruling, and whether the oversight mechanism of the ombudsman and the court is strong enough to safeguard Lubaba's long-term interests. For her, the ruling does not close the story; it opens a long road of recovery. And for the electricity infrastructure system, the larger question remains how to make safety responsibility an everyday practice, rather than something that appears only after a tragedy has already occurred.
Cầu thủ liên quan